• Home
  • Free Report
  • Features
    • Features
    • Quick Videos
    • Product Updates
  • Pricing
  • Reviews
  • Blog
  • About
    • About
    • FAQ
    • Certified Partners
  • Contact

BrokerEngine

Menu

  • Home
  • Free Report
  • Features
    • Features
    • Quick Videos
    • Product Updates
  • Pricing
  • Reviews
  • Blog
  • About
    • About
    • FAQ
    • Certified Partners
  • Contact
1300 998 791Request a DemoFree Demo
  • Home
  • Free Report
  • Features
    • Features
    • Quick Videos
    • Product Updates
  • Pricing
  • Reviews
  • Blog
  • About
    • About
    • FAQ
    • Certified Partners
  • Contact

Lead Management Best Practices for Mortgage Brokers

14 Feb 2023 by BrokerEngine,

Many mortgage brokers tend to put a lot of emphasis on lead generation and sales conversion, while downplaying the importance of lead management. 

Good lead management means making the most of every sales lead and ensuring that opportunities never “slip through the cracks”. 

In this article we review data-driven lead management best practices and also provide you with mortgage broker-specific automation examples for implementing bulletproof lead management in your practice. 

Let’s get started!

What Is Lead Management? 

Lead management is the process of connecting lead generation to sales. It involves techniques such as lead response, persistence, qualification, and nurturing to improve the value of leads in the sales process.

Lead Management Meme

3 Data-Driven Lead Management Best Practices 

With trillions being spent on marketing and lead generation every year, a lot of research effort has gone into establishing how to maximise the value of that marketing. 

This lead management infographic from Inside Sales summarises key research findings that we’ll unpack below.

#1. Respond To Leads Within 5 MINUTES if Possible 

Research shows that a sub-5 minute response to inbound leads is your best bet for contacting a prospect on the first attempt.

If you wait 10 minutes, your chances of contact on the first attempt decrease by 10 TIMES. 

Contacts Made From First Dial Chart

ACTION STEPS FOR MORTGAGE BROKERS: 

  • Where possible, empower your Client Service Manager or other “first responder” to jump on new leads as a matter of urgency. 
  • If you are responsible for responding to leads directly, it’s not always possible to drop what you’re doing and call a lead. But when you are available, a rapid response is most effective.

Example Lead Management Automation Workflow

Here’s a sample lead management workflow to help facilitate a fast response and ensure leads don’t slip through the cracks:

#2. Be Persistent With Lead Followup (6 Calls / 12 Touches Is Optimal)

Research also shows that most companies give up on leads too soon.  

It turns out that 6 phone calls is the optimal number of attempts if you want to maximise your contact rate (without getting into diminishing returns).

  • A mix of phone calls / emails / text messages works best. 
  • Keep track of lead followup in a trusted workflow system such as BrokerEngine. 
  • Follow up at the best time of day where possible (see next section). 
"Chance of making contact" chart

#3. Attempt Lead Followup At The Optimal Time Of Day and Day of Week

The research also reveals that some times of day are better than others for making contact. 

The golden time is 4pm to 5pm (although this may be more suited to a B2B audience).  If you’re dealing with consumers, you may also see good results at 8am to 9am, and also just after work, around 5pm to 5.30pm. 

Contacts Made From First Dial Chart

While we’re discussing optimal contact times, some days of the week are better than others.  Wednesday and Thursday should definitely be top of your list for callbacks:

Contacts Made From First Dial By Day

Most Companies Are Weak In Lead Management! 

Research proves that many companies are weak in the area of lead management. This provides you with an easy opportunity to differentiate yourself. 

Just look at these industry norms:

  • Speed of Response: The average phone response time is 44 hours. The optimal phone response time is 5 minutes.  
  • Persistency of Response: The average number of “touches” is 4.5 touches.  The optimal number of touches across phone/email/SMS is 12 touches. 
  • Phone Response: 30% of leads are not responded to at all!  The optimal approach is to….actually respond 🙃. 

Conclusion and Next Steps

We get it: lead management isn’t the most exciting aspect of marketing and new business generation.

However, it is one area in which it is easy to systemise and deploy best practices. 

Not every lead will be contactable, and not every prospect will do business with you, but it’s your job to get the best results from a given batch of leads.

Hopefully this article has given you some quick wins you can put into practice this week.  And if you could do with a more robust system to streamline and automate lead management in your practice, we invite you to check out the latest demo of BrokerEngine software. 

Book a BrokerEngine Demo

be-logo

  • HOME
  • FEATURES
  • VIDEOS
  • PRICING
  • REVIEWS
  • ABOUT
  • FAQ
  • BLOG
  • CONTACT
© 2025 BrokerEngine
Terms of Service Cookies Terms & Conditions Privacy Policy
User Login

Nearly there: Please tell us where to send your plan

Get Free & Instant Access To:
The ULTIMATE Mortgage Broker Marketing Plan

We respect your privacy.

If you choose to provide your information, it will be used to offer or provide you with our services and/or the services of our associates. We may also ask you for feedback. We may not be able to assist you if you do not provide your information. We may need to disclose your information to other organisations providing services to us, that may be overseas. If you would prefer not to receive marketing material you can always unsubscribe. We include a simple unsubscribe feature on all electronic marketing materials that we send. Our Privacy Policy (which is available on this website) contains information about how you can access your personal information and request corrections or lodge a complaint. Information about who we are and how to contact us is available on this website.

Nearly there: please enter your details and let us know where to send your detailed Blueprint…

Get Free And Instant Access To
The Broker Blueprint: How To Attract, Sell and Deliver Like A 9-Figure Broker
(i.e. Settling More Than $100M Per Year)

We respect your privacy.

If you choose to provide your information, it will be used to offer or provide you with our services and/or the services of our associates. We may also ask you for feedback. We may not be able to assist you if you do not provide your information. We may need to disclose your information to other organisations providing services to us, that may be overseas. If you would prefer not to receive marketing material you can always unsubscribe. We include a simple unsubscribe feature on all electronic marketing materials that we send. Our Privacy Policy (which is available on this website) contains information about how you can access your personal information and request corrections or lodge a complaint. Information about who we are and how to contact us is available on this website.

Nearly there: Please enter your details and let us know where to send your guide…

Ultimate List of Mortgage Broker Lead Generation Ideas

31 Practical Ways To Start Conversations With Highly-Qualified Mortgage Prospects

We respect your privacy.

If you choose to provide your information, it will be used to offer or provide you with our services and/or the services of our associates. We may also ask you for feedback. We may not be able to assist you if you do not provide your information. We may need to disclose your information to other organisations providing services to us, that may be overseas. If you would prefer not to receive marketing material you can always unsubscribe. We include a simple unsubscribe feature on all electronic marketing materials that we send. Our Privacy Policy (which is available on this website) contains information about how you can access your personal information and request corrections or lodge a complaint. Information about who we are and how to contact us is available on this website.

Nearly there: Please enter your details and let us know where to send your guide…

The Ideal Mortgage Broker Sales Process
How To Convert +95% Of Prospects Into New Clients, Like Clockwork

We respect your privacy.

If you choose to provide your information, it will be used to offer or provide you with our services and/or the services of our associates. We may also ask you for feedback. We may not be able to assist you if you do not provide your information. We may need to disclose your information to other organisations providing services to us, that may be overseas. If you would prefer not to receive marketing material you can always unsubscribe. We include a simple unsubscribe feature on all electronic marketing materials that we send. Our Privacy Policy (which is available on this website) contains information about how you can access your personal information and request corrections or lodge a complaint. Information about who we are and how to contact us is available on this website.
If you choose to provide your information, it will be used to offer or provide you with our services and/or the services of our associates. We may also ask you for feedback. We may not be able to assist you if you do not provide your information. We may need to disclose your information to other organisations providing services to us, that may be overseas. If you would prefer not to receive marketing material you can always unsubscribe. We include a simple unsubscribe feature on all electronic marketing materials that we send. Our Privacy Policy (which is available on this website) contains information about how you can access your personal information and request corrections or lodge a complaint. Information about who we are and how to contact us is available on this website.
If you choose to provide your information, it will be used to offer or provide you with our services and/or the services of our associates. We may also ask you for feedback. We may not be able to assist you if you do not provide your information. We may need to disclose your information to other organisations providing services to us, that may be overseas. If you would prefer not to receive marketing material you can always unsubscribe. We include a simple unsubscribe feature on all electronic marketing materials that we send. Our Privacy Policy (which is available on this website) contains information about how you can access your personal information and request corrections or lodge a complaint. Information about who we are and how to contact us is available on this website.

Nearly there: please tell us where to send your newsletter…

Sign up to the BrokerEngine Newsletter

Name(Required)
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

We respect your privacy.

If you choose to provide your information, it will be used to offer or provide you with our services and/or the services of our associates. We may also ask you for feedback. We may not be able to assist you if you do not provide your information. We may need to disclose your information to other organisations providing services to us, that may be overseas. If you would prefer not to receive marketing material you can always unsubscribe. We include a simple unsubscribe feature on all electronic marketing materials that we send. Our Privacy Policy (which is available on this website) contains information about how you can access your personal information and request corrections or lodge a complaint. Information about who we are and how to contact us is available on this website.

Nearly there: please enter your details and let us know where to send your 38-page PDF…

Download The PDF Version:
“The Ultimate List Of Mortgage Broker Lead Generation Ideas”

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
We respect your privacy.